So, is it hard to win a malpractice lawsuit? The reality is that these cases are among the toughest in New York’s legal system. A patient must clear high legal hurdles, present complex medical proof, and often take on hospitals or insurers with deep resources. The road is far from easy, yet justice is not out of reach with the right legal team. At the Law Office of Cohen & Jaffe – Long Island Personal Injury Lawyers, we know these cases are not just legal disputes—they represent lives disrupted by broken trust. Families arrive at us in moments of uncertainty, and we stand ready to pursue accountability with determination and care.
Contact a Long Island Personal Injury Lawyer Near You
How Hard Is It to Win a Malpractice Lawsuit in New York?
In New York, winning a malpractice claim requires showing more than a bad medical outcome. The law asks whether a healthcare provider deviated from the accepted standard of care and whether that mistake directly caused harm. That threshold is demanding, and medical institutions usually have significant resources to fight back.
Under the New York Civil Practice Law and Rules (CPLR § 214-a), most victims have two years and six months to file a lawsuit, with some exceptions, such as the “continuous treatment” doctrine. Courts hold plaintiffs to a rigorous standard of proof, meaning juries need clear evidence that negligence—not just an unfortunate medical complication—caused the injury.
What Factors Determine the Outcome of a Medical Malpractice Case
Every malpractice case has unique circumstances, but several hurdles consistently influence outcomes:
- Strict legal standards: Courts require proof of negligence and causation, not just a medical complication.
- Burden of proof: Plaintiffs must be responsible for proving all four required elements of malpractice.
- Certificate of Merit: This legal requirement confirms that a qualified physician has reviewed the case and found a reasonable basis for the claim.
- Strength of medical evidence: Detailed records, test results, and treatment notes are critical.
- Expert testimony: Courts rely heavily on specialists to explain how care fell below accepted standards.
- Causation: Proving that the doctor’s negligence—not the natural progression of an illness—directly caused the injury is often the most brutal battle.
- Severity of harm: Permanent disability, significant financial loss, or wrongful death often make cases stronger.
- Defense strategies: Hospitals and insurers commonly argue that complications were inevitable or unrelated to negligence.
These elements highlight why so many malpractice claims face challenges in court.
What Damages Can Be Available if You Win a Medical Malpractice Case?
Compensation in malpractice lawsuits varies depending on the impact of the injury. Common categories of damages include:
- Medical costs: Expenses for past and future care, rehabilitation, or assistive devices.
- Lost income: Wages lost during recovery and reduced earning capacity in the future.
- Pain and suffering: Compensation for the physical and emotional toll of the injury.
- Loss of enjoyment of life: The impact on daily activities, independence, and personal relationships.
- Wrongful death damages: When negligence causes a fatality, families may pursue damages for funeral costs, lost support, and companionship.
In New York, there are no statutory caps on medical malpractice damages, which means juries can award amounts that reflect the true extent of harm.
“I had an understanding that everyday people had accidents through no fault of their own,” he recalls. “I think that’s what pushed me into becoming a lawyer.”
Stephen M. Cohen
What Evidence Do You Need to Prove Medical Malpractice?
Evidence is the cornerstone of any malpractice case. To demonstrate negligence, plaintiffs typically need:
- Complete medical records documenting treatment and procedures.
- Expert evaluations from specialists in the same field as the defendant.
- Diagnostic imaging and lab results showing what was missed or misinterpreted.
- Witness statements from nurses, staff, or family who observed the care.
- Proof of damages, such as employment records, therapy bills, or testimony on quality of life changes.
According to the New York City Bar Association, malpractice occurs when a provider fails to follow the accepted standard of practice and injures the patient.
Because jurors often lack medical expertise, expert testimony becomes critical. Specialists help explain how a provider’s conduct strayed from professional norms. Yet even with experts, juries may be skeptical and require overwhelming evidence to side with the plaintiff. That is why careful preparation, clear presentation, and strategic storytelling are essential in these cases.
Contact a Long Island Personal Injury Lawyer for a Free Consultation
So, is it hard to win a malpractice lawsuit in New York? The truth is that these cases are challenging—but with the right team, they can be won. At the Law Office of Cohen & Jaffe – Long Island Personal Injury Lawyers, we understand how devastating medical negligence can be, and we are here to fight for you. Call us today at 516-358-6900 for a free consultation and let us review your situation in detail.